
After years in which the art world seemed obsessed with discovering the next big name, are collectors beginning to look backwards?
According to London dealer Dotahn Pissarro-Stern, there are signs that some buyers are returning to artists whose importance has already been established by history.
And one artist provides a particularly interesting example: Camille Pissarro.
TOO MUCH ART, TOO MANY FAIRS?
The international art calendar has never been busier.
Frieze, Art Basel, TEFAF and countless other fairs, exhibitions and satellite events now compete almost continuously for collectors’ attention.
At the same time, galleries are reporting difficult trading conditions, some spaces are closing and collectors are being introduced to an endless stream of new artists.
Pissarro-Stern believes those two things may be connected.
Collectors are being asked to absorb more artists, attend more events and make increasingly expensive decisions about artists whose long-term importance may still be uncertain.
For some, the excitement of discovering something new remains a major part of collecting.
For others, the sheer volume may be becoming exhausting.
CAMILLE PISSARRO IS MOVING AGAIN
Stern Pissarro Gallery specialises largely in established Impressionist, Post-Impressionist, modern and contemporary names.
And over the past 18 months, the gallery says it has noticed an interesting change.
For much of the previous decade, Camille Pissarro’s auction market had been relatively subdued, particularly while prices for certain contemporary artists were accelerating.
That has started to change.
Prices have strengthened and, more importantly from the gallery’s perspective, works that had remained in stock have started selling.
Stern Pissarro says it has sold more Pissarro oil paintings in a single year than ever before.
PROVEN OR PROJECTED?
That raises an interesting question for collectors.
When you buy an established artist, much of the historical question has already been answered.
We know where Picasso, Warhol, Monet, Pissarro and Hockney sit within art history. Their careers have been documented, exhibited, studied and tested through generations of collectors.
With an emerging artist, the situation is completely different.
You are buying much earlier in the story.
That can be incredibly exciting. Discovering an artist before wider recognition is one of the great attractions of collecting contemporary art.
But it also means distinguishing between genuine artistic development and short-term market hype.
Not every artist commanding attention today will still command it in 20 or 30 years.
BUT THAT DOESN’T MEAN EMERGING ART IS DEAD
It would be a mistake to interpret the shift as collectors abandoning contemporary or emerging artists.
Every established artist was once unknown.
The difference is how collectors approach them.
A strong collection does not necessarily have to choose between the security of art history and the excitement of discovering something new.
It can contain both.
Established artists can provide a collection with recognisable historical foundations, while carefully selected emerging artists can introduce something completely different: the opportunity to follow and participate in an artist’s developing career.
The challenge is understanding which is which.
BUY THE ART, NOT THE NOISE
Perhaps the most interesting idea to come from Pissarro-Stern’s observations is the distinction between an artist whose importance is proven and one whose importance is still projected.
Neither automatically makes an artwork good or bad.
But collectors should understand the difference.
Markets move. Trends disappear. Galleries change direction. Artists move in and out of fashion.
Quality, provenance, scarcity, career development and genuine cultural significance tend to matter over much longer periods.
That is why the current movement back towards historically established artists is worth watching.
It may not represent the end of the contemporary art boom.
It may simply indicate that collectors are becoming more selective.
And perhaps that is healthy for the entire market.
Great collecting has never been about chasing every new name. It is about knowing when you are buying history, and recognising when you might be watching history being made.
Fractional Gallery | Art News & Market